Advertisement

Motivational strategies to improve adherence to physical activity in breast cancer survivors: A systematic review and meta-analysis

      Highlights

      • Physical activity is a vital element in maintaining health in breast cancer survivors.
      • Despite its importance, adherence to exercise is generally low.
      • Strategies to increase participant motivation, such as step tracking and motivational interviewing, increase adherence to physical activity and exercise.

      Abstract

      Two behavioral change-based strategies for promoting adherence to physical activity (PA) suggested to have the greatest potential are the pedometer and Motivational Interviewing (MI). However, there are no comparisons between these two strategies identifying which one is more effective for improving PA adherence. This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to determine which PA motivation strategy is more effective for promoting adherence to self-directed PA in female breast cancer survivors. Studies implementing self-directed PA which used a step tracker and/or MI for motivation in female breast cancer survivors were identified from the following databases at two timepoints, September 2019 and June 2020: CENTRAL, PubMed, CINAHL, PsycINFO, and Sportdiscuss. Sixteen randomized controlled trials (RCTs) were selected for data extraction, whereas ten RCTs were included in meta-analysis. Meta-analysis was performed on pooled data to estimate the standardized mean differences in PA duration and step count, and 95% confidence intervals. The number of participants meeting PA recommendations was also analyzed. Subgroup analysis was performed for three motivational strategies (pedometer combined with counselling, with print material or with motivational interviewing). Meta-analysis showed that pedometer combined with another intervention has a small effect on step count (p = 0.03) and a moderate effect on duration of moderate-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) (p = <0.0001) compared to controls. Additionally, motivational strategies increase the number of participants who meet a PA goal (p = 0.005). The findings of this review endorse the use of a step tracker combined with counselling, print material or MI based on behavioral change theory. This approach provided the most consistent positive effect on adherence to self-directed PA among breast cancer survivors. Future studies should evaluate differences between measures of adherence to self-directed PA, to identify the best motivation strategy for improving patient adherence and health outcomes.
      Systematic review registration: PROSPERO Registration number CRD42020148542

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to Maturitas
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Bray F.
        • Ferlay J.
        • Soerjomataram I.
        • Siegel R.L.
        • Torre L.A.
        • Jemal A.
        Global cancer statistics 2018: GLOBOCAN estimates of incidence and mortality worldwide for 36 cancers in 185 countries.
        CA Cancer J. Clin. 2018; 68: 394-424
        • Li N.
        • Deng Y.
        • Zhou L.
        • Tian T.
        • Yang S.
        • Wu Y.
        • Zheng Y.
        • Zhai Z.
        • Hao Q.
        • Song D.
        Global burden of breast cancer and attributable risk factors in 195 countries and territories, from 1990 to 2017: results from the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017.
        J. Hematol. Oncol. 2019; 12: 1-12
        • Hewitt M.E.
        • Greenfield S.
        • Stovall E.
        From Cancer Patient to Cancer Survivor.
        National Academies Press, Washington, D.C.2006 ([electronic resource] : lost in transitionc2006)
        • Hodgkinson K.
        • Butow P.
        • Hunt G.E.
        • Pendlebury S.
        • Hobbs K.M.
        • Wain G.
        Breast cancer survivors’ supportive care needs 2–10 years after diagnosis.
        Support. Care Cancer. 2007; 15: 515-523
        • Jones J.
        • Grunfeld E.
        Specific Challenges in Optimizing Health Care for Cancer Survivors.
        in: Feuerstein M. Ganz P.A. Health Services for Cancer Survivors: Practice, Policy and Research. Eds. Springer New York, New York, NY2011: 3-25
        • Paxton R.J.
        • Phillips K.L.
        • Jones L.A.
        • Chang S.
        • Taylor W.C.
        • Courneya K.S.
        • Pierce J.P.
        Associations among physical activity, body mass index, and health-related quality of life by race/ethnicity in a diverse sample of breast cancer survivors.
        Cancer. 2012; 118: 4024-4031
        • Huang H.-.P.
        • Wen F.-.H.
        • Tsai J.-.C.
        • Lin Y.-.C.
        • Shun S.-.C.
        • Chang H.-.K.
        • Wang J.-.S.
        • Jane S.-.W.
        • Chen M.-.C.
        • Chen M.-.L.
        Adherence to prescribed exercise time and intensity declines as the exercise program proceeds: findings from women under treatment for breast cancer.
        Support. Care Cancer. 2015; 23: 2061-2071
        • Jansons P.S.
        • Haines T.P.
        • O’Brien L.
        Interventions to achieve ongoing exercise adherence for adults with chronic health conditions who have completed a supervised exercise program: systematic review and meta-analysis.
        Clin. Rehabil. 2017; (0269215516653995)
        • Lahart I.M.
        • Metsios G.S.
        • Nevill A.M.
        • Kitas G.D.
        • Carmichael A.R.
        Randomised controlled trial of a home-based physical activity intervention in breast cancer survivors.
        BMC Cancer. 2016; 16: 234
        • Arem H.
        • Sorkin M.
        • Cartmel B.
        • Fiellin M.
        • Capozza S.
        • Harrigan M.
        • Ercolano E.
        • Zhou Y.
        • Sanft T.
        • Gross C.
        Exercise adherence in a randomized trial of exercise on aromatase inhibitor arthralgias in breast cancer survivors: the Hormones and Physical Exercise (HOPE) study.
        Journal of Cancer Survivorship. 2016; 10: 654-662
        • Duncan K.
        • Pozehl B.
        • Norman J.F.
        • Hertzog M.
        A self-directed adherence management program for patients with heart failure completing combined aerobic and resistance exercise training.
        Appl. Nurs. Res. 2011; 24: 207-214
        • Cadmus-Bertram L.
        • Marcus B.H.
        • Patterson R.E.
        • Parker B.A.
        • Morey B.L.
        Use of the Fitbit to Measure Adherence to a Physical Activity Intervention Among Overweight or Obese, Postmenopausal Women: self-Monitoring Trajectory During 16 Weeks.
        JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2015; 3 (e96-e96)
        • De Jesus S.
        • Fitzgeorge L.
        • Unsworth K.
        • Massel D.
        • Suskin N.
        • Prapavessis H.
        • Sanatani M.
        Feasibility of an exercise intervention for fatigued breast cancer patients at a community-based cardiac rehabilitation program.
        Cancer Manag Res. 2017; 9: 29-39
        • Byrne H.
        • Caulfield B.
        • De Vito G.
        Effects of Self-directed Exercise Programmes on Individuals with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: a Systematic Review Evaluating Their Effect on HbA1c and Other Metabolic Outcomes, Physical Characteristics, Cardiorespiratory Fitness and Functional Outcomes.
        Sports Medicine. 2017; 47: 717-733
        • Dittus K.L.
        • Gramling R.E.
        • Ades P.A.
        Exercise interventions for individuals with advanced cancer: a systematic review.
        Prev. Med. 2017; 104: 124-132
        • Winters-Stone K.M.
        • Dobek J.
        • Bennett J.A.
        • Nail L.M.
        • Leo M.C.
        • Schwartz A.
        The effect of resistance training on muscle strength and physical function in older, postmenopausal breast cancer survivors: a randomized controlled trial.
        J Cancer Surviv. 2012; 6: 189-199
        • Rossi A.
        • Friel C.
        • Carter L.
        • Garber C.E.
        Effects of Theory-Based Behavioral Interventions on Physical Activity Among Overweight and Obese Female Cancer Survivors: a Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials.
        Integr. Cancer Ther. 2017; 1534735417734911
        • Milne H.M.
        • Wallman K.E.
        • Guilfoyle A.
        • Gordon S.
        • Courneya K.S.
        Self-determination theory and physical activity among breast cancer survivors.
        Journal of Sport and exercise Psychology. 2008; 30: 23-38
        • Vallance J.K.H.
        • Courneya K.S.
        • Plotnikoff R.C.
        • Mackey J.R.
        Analyzing Theoretical Mechanisms of Physical Activity Behavior Change in Breast Cancer Survivors: results from the Activity Promotion (ACTION) Trial.
        Ann. Behav. Med. 2008; 35: 150-158
        • Bluethmann S.M.
        • Bartholomew L.K.
        • Murphy C.C.
        • Vernon S.W.
        Use of theory in behavior change interventions: an analysis of programs to increase physical activity in posttreatment breast cancer survivors.
        Health Educ. Behav. 2017; 44: 245-253
        • Bachmann C.
        • Oesch P.
        • Bachmann S.
        Recommendations for improving adherence to home-based exercise: a systematic review.
        Physikalische Medizin, Rehabilitationsmedizin, Kurortmedizin. 2018; 28: 20-31
        • Teixeira P.J.
        • Silva M.N.
        • Mata J.
        • Palmeira A.L.
        • Markland D.
        Motivation, self-determination, and long-term weight control.
        International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity. 2012; 9: 22
        • Wilson P.M.
        • Mack D.E.
        • Grattan K.P.
        Understanding motivation for exercise: a self-determination theory perspective.
        Canadian Psychology/Psychologie canadienne. 2008; 49: 250
        • Briki W.
        Motivation toward Physical Exercise and Subjective Wellbeing: the Mediating Role of Trait Self-Control.
        Front Psychol. 2016; 7 (1546-1546)
        • Levesque C.S.
        • Williams G.C.
        • Elliot D.
        • Pickering M.A.
        • Bodenhamer B.
        • Finley P.J.
        Validating the theoretical structure of the Treatment Self-Regulation Questionnaire (TSRQ) across three different health behaviors.
        Health Educ. Res. 2006; 22: 691-702
        • Munson S.A.
        • Consolvo S.
        Exploring goal-setting, rewards, self-monitoring, and sharing to motivate physical activity.
        in: 2012 6th international conference on pervasive computing technologies for healthcare (pervasivehealth) and workshops. IEEE, 2012: 25-32
        • Perry C.K.
        • Rosenfeld A.G.
        • Bennett J.A.
        • Potempa K.
        Heart-to-Heart: promoting walking in rural women through motivational interviewing and group support.
        J. Cardiovasc. Nurs. 2007; 22: 304-312
        • Gell N.M.
        • Grover K.W.
        • Humble M.
        • Sexton M.
        • Dittus K.
        Efficacy, feasibility, and acceptability of a novel technology-based intervention to support physical activity in cancer survivors.
        Support. Care Cancer. 2017; 25: 1291-1300
        • Tudor-Locke C.
        Taking steps toward increased physical activity: using pedometers to measure and motivate, President's Council on.
        Physical Fitness and Sports Research Digest. 2002;
        • Bennett J.A.
        • Lyons K.S.
        • Winters-Stone K.
        • Nail L.M.
        • Scherer J.
        Motivational interviewing to increase physical activity in long-term cancer survivors: a randomized controlled trial.
        Nurs. Res. 2007; 56: 18-27
        • Pinto B.M.
        • Ciccolo J.T.
        Physical activity motivation and cancer survivorship.
        Physical Activity and Cancer. Springer, 2010: 367-387
        • Sheppard V.B.
        • Hicks J.
        • Makambi K.
        • Hurtado-de-Mendoza A.
        • Demark-Wahnefried W.
        • Adams-Campbell L.
        The feasibility and acceptability of a diet and exercise trial in overweight and obese black breast cancer survivors: the Stepping STONE study.
        Contemp Clin Trials. 2016; 46: 106-113
        • Bandura A.
        Social cognitive theory of self-regulation.
        Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process. 1991; 50: 248-287
        • Lewis B.A.
        • Napolitano M.A.
        • Buman M.P.
        • Williams D.M.
        • Nigg C.R.
        Future directions in physical activity intervention research: expanding our focus to sedentary behaviors, technology, and dissemination.
        J. Behav. Med. 2017; 40: 112-126
        • Tudor-Locke C.
        • Craig C.L.
        • Aoyagi Y.
        • Bell R.C.
        • Croteau K.A.
        • De Bourdeaudhuij I.
        • Ewald B.
        • Gardner A.W.
        • Hatano Y.
        • Lutes L.D.
        • Matsudo S.M.
        • Ramirez-Marrero F.A.
        • Rogers L.Q.
        • Rowe D.A.
        • Schmidt M.D.
        • Tully M.A.
        • Blair S.N.
        How many steps/day are enough? For older adults and special populations.
        Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2011; 8 (80-80)
        • Brunet J.
        • Burke S.M.
        • Sabiston C.M.
        The benefits of being self-determined in promoting physical activity and affective well-being among women recently treated for breast cancer.
        Psychooncology. 2013; 22: 2245-2252
        • Rogers L.Q.
        • Courneya K.S.
        • Anton P.M.
        • Hopkins-Price P.
        • Verhulst S.
        • Vicari S.K.
        • Robbs R.S.
        • Mocharnuk R.
        • McAuley E.
        Effects of the BEAT Cancer physical activity behavior change intervention on physical activity, aerobic fitness, and quality of life in breast cancer survivors: a multicenter randomized controlled trial.
        Breast Cancer Res. Treat. 2015; 149: 109-119
        • Shamseer L.
        • Moher D.
        • Clarke M.
        • Ghersi D.
        • Liberati A.
        • Petticrew M.
        • Shekelle P.
        • Stewart L.A.
        Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015: elaboration and explanation.
        The BMJ. 2015; 349: g7647
        • Feuerstein M.
        Defining cancer survivorship.
        Journal of Cancer Survivorship: Research and Practice. 2007; 1: 5-7
      1. World Health Organization, Global strategy on diet, physical activity and health, 2018. https://www.who.int/nmh/wha/59/dpas/en/.

        • Cox K.L.
        • Burke V.
        • Gorely T.J.
        • Beilin L.
        • Puddey I.B.
        Controlled comparison of retention and adherence in home-vs center-initiated exercise interventions in women ages 40–65 years: the SWEAT study (Sedentary Women Exercise Adherence Trial).
        Prev. Med. 2003; 36: 17-29
      2. Covidence, Better systematic review management, n.d. https://www.covidence.org/.

        • Higgins J.
        • Altman D.G.
        Assessing Risk of Bias in Included Studies.
        Wiley-Blackwell, West Sussex2008
        • Barker A.L.
        • Talevski J.
        • Morello R.T.
        • Brand C.A.
        • Rahmann A.E.
        • Urquhart D.M.
        Effectiveness of aquatic exercise for musculoskeletal conditions: a meta-analysis.
        Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 2014; 95: 1776-1786
        • Talevski J.
        • Sanders K.M.
        • Duque G.
        • Connaughton C.
        • Beauchamp A.
        • Green D.
        • Millar L.
        • Brennan-Olsen S.L.
        Effect of clinical care pathways on quality of life and physical function after fragility fracture: a meta-analysis.
        J. Am. Med. Dir. Assoc. 2019; 20 (e1-926. e11): 926
        • Higgins J G.S.
        Cochrane Handbook For Systematic Reviews of Interventions.
        John Wiley & Sons Ltd, London2008
        • Short C.E.
        • James E.L.
        • Girgis A.
        • D’Souza M.I.
        • Plotnikoff R.C.
        Main outcomes of the Move More for Life Trial: a randomised controlled trial examining the effects of tailored-print and targeted-print materials for promoting physical activity among post-treatment breast cancer survivors.
        Psychooncology. 2015; 24: 771-778
        • Hirschey R.
        • Kimmick G.
        • Hockenberry M.
        • Shaw R.
        • Pan W.
        • Page C.
        • Lipkus I.
        A randomized phase II trial of MOVING ON: an intervention to increase exercise outcome expectations among breast cancer survivors.
        Psychooncology. 2018; 27: 2450-2457
        • Pinto B.M.
        • Papandonatos G.D.
        • Goldstein M.G.
        A randomized trial to promote physical activity among breast cancer patients.
        Health Psychol. 2013; 32: 616
        • Pinto B.M.
        • Stein K.
        • Dunsiger S.
        Peers promoting physical activity among breast cancer survivors: a randomized controlled trial.
        Health Psychol. 2015; 34: 463
        • Vallance J.K.
        • Courneya K.S.
        • Plotnikoff R.C.
        • Yasui Y.
        • Mackey J.R.
        Randomized controlled trial of the effects of print materials and step pedometers on physical activity and quality of life in breast cancer survivors.
        J. Clin. Oncol. 2007; 25: 2352-2359
        • Vallance J.K.
        • Courneya K.S.
        • Plotnikoff R.C.
        • Dinu I.
        • Mackey J.R.
        Maintenance of physical activity in breast cancer survivors after a randomized trial.
        Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 2008; 40: 173-180
        • Lynch B.M.
        • Nguyen N.H.
        • Moore M.M.
        • Reeves M.M.
        • Rosenberg D.E.
        • Boyle T.
        • Vallance J.K.
        • Milton S.
        • Friedenreich C.M.
        • English D.R.
        A randomized controlled trial of a wearable technology-based intervention for increasing moderate to vigorous physical activity and reducing sedentary behavior in breast cancer survivors: the ACTIVATE Trial.
        Cancer. 2019; 125: 2846-2855
        • Lahart I.M.
        • Metsios G.S.
        • Nevill A.M.
        • Kitas G.D.
        • Carmichael A.R.
        Randomised controlled trial of a home-based physical activity intervention in breast cancer survivors.
        BMC Cancer. 2016; 16: 1-14
        • Baruth M.
        • Wilcox S.
        • Der Ananian C.
        • Heiney S.
        Effects of home-based walking on quality of life and fatigue outcomes in early stage breast cancer survivors: a 12-week pilot study.
        Journal of Physical Activity and Health. 2015; 12: S110-S118
        • Basen-Engquist K.
        • Taylor C.L.C.
        • Rosenblum C.
        • Smith M.A.
        • Shinn E.H.
        • Greisinger A.
        • Gregg X.
        • Massey P.
        • Valero V.
        • Rivera E.
        Randomized pilot test of a lifestyle physical activity intervention for breast cancer survivors.
        Patient Educ. Couns. 2006; 64: 225-234
        • Singh B.
        • Spence R.R.
        • Sandler C.X.
        • Tanner J.
        • Hayes S.C.
        Feasibility and effect of a physical activity counselling session with or without provision of an activity tracker on maintenance of physical activity in women with breast cancer—A randomised controlled trial.
        J. Sci. Med. Sport. 2020; 23: 283-290
        • Hartman S.J.
        • Nelson S.H.
        • Myers E.
        • Natarajan L.
        • Sears D.D.
        • Palmer B.W.
        • Weiner L.S.
        • Parker B.A.
        • Patterson R.E.
        Randomized controlled trial of increasing physical activity on objectively measured and self-reported cognitive functioning among breast cancer survivors: the memory & motion study.
        Cancer. 2018; 124: 192-202
        • Sterne J.A.C.
        • Egger M.
        • Moher D.
        Cochrane Handbook of Systematic Reviews of Intervention.
        John Wiley & Sons Inc., West Sussex2008
        • Pinto B.M.
        • Frierson G.M.
        • Rabin C.
        • Trunzo J.J.
        • Marcus B.H.
        Home-based physical activity intervention for breast cancer patients.
        J. Clin. Oncol. 2005; 23: 3577-3587
        • Pinto B.M.
        • Rabin C.
        • Papandonatos G.D.
        • Frierson G.M.
        • Trunzo J.J.
        • Marcus B.H.
        Maintenance of effects of a home-based physical activity program among breast cancer survivors.
        Support. Care Cancer. 2008; 16: 1279-1289
        • Pope Z.C.
        • Zeng N.
        • Zhang R.
        • Lee H.Y.
        • Gao Z.
        Effectiveness of combined smartwatch and social media intervention on breast cancer survivor health outcomes: a 10-week pilot randomized trial.
        J Clin Med. 2018; 7: 140